Updated October 14, 2026 · ShieldCue Editorial Team

Top secure email and messaging compared

60 providers, ranked on the terms we checked.

We earn a commission when you sign up through links on this site. Partner status can affect where a brand appears in our rankings. How we rank

Top secure email and messaging compared
#	Provider	Score	Features	Key facts	Actions
1	ProtonTop pick 40% off Pass Plus	9.3/10	No logs Streaming Travel Business Free	Price from: $4.99 Free plan limits: Unlimited logins, notes, credit cards and devices; 10 hide-my-email aliases; passkeys and password health alerts; no 2FA authenticator, secure sharing, file attachments or dark web monitoring End-to-end encryption: All fields end-to-end encrypted: passwords, usernames, web addresses, credit cards, note contents and metadata; 256-bit AES-GCM vaults; only the user can decrypt, Proton cannot	Review Compare Visit
2	Proton Mail 30-day money-back guarantee on Pass Plus and Proton Unlimited: 30 days	9.0/10	Free Budget	Price from: $4.99 Free plan limits: Unlimited logins, notes, credit cards and devices; 10 hide-my-email aliases; passkeys on all devices; no vault or item sharing End-to-end encryption: All fields end-to-end encrypted: passwords, usernames, web addresses, credit cards, note contents and metadata; 256-bit AES-GCM vaults; only the user can decrypt, Proton cannot	Review Compare Visit
3	Proton Pass 40% off Pass Plus	9.0/10	Free	Price from: $4.99 Free plan limits: Unlimited logins, notes, credit cards and devices; 10 hide-my-email aliases; passkeys on all devices; no vault or item sharing End-to-end encryption: All fields end-to-end encrypted: passwords, usernames, web addresses, credit cards, note contents and metadata; 256-bit AES-GCM vaults; only the user can decrypt, Proton cannot	Review Compare Visit
4	Fastmail Free trial on signup: 30 days	9.3/10	Business	Price from: €4 Free plan limits: No free plan; 30-day free trial End-to-end encryption: No end-to-end encryption in Fastmail's own apps; PGP or S/MIME only via third-party apps	Review Compare Visit
5	Proton AG	9.3/10	No logs Streaming Business Free	Free plan limits: No data or speed limits, no ads, no time limit, 1 device, servers in 10 countries randomly selected, medium speed. End-to-end encryption: The VPN connection from the user's device to Proton's servers; Proton also markets Proton for Business with end-to-end encryption. Jurisdiction: CH	Review Compare Visit
6	Fastmail 30-day free trial: 30 days free	9.0/10		Price from: €4 Free plan limits: No free plan; 30-day free trial End-to-end encryption: No end-to-end encryption in Fastmail's own apps; PGP or S/MIME only via third-party apps	Review Compare Visit
6	WiTopia	9.0/10	Streaming Travel Business Free Budget	Price from: $3.99 Free plan limits: Single Gmail, Yahoo or Microsoft consumer address free forever End-to-end encryption: Email and attachments	Review Compare Visit
7	Internxt Christmas savings: 80% off	8.8/10	No logs Business Free Budget	Price from: €9.99 Free plan limits: 1 GB of encrypted cloud storage, free for life End-to-end encryption: Emails and attachments in Internxt Mail are end-to-end encrypted with post-quantum and zero-knowledge encryption, so only the user can read them	Review Compare Visit
8	Cloaked, Inc. 14 days free	8.6/10	No logs Business Free Budget	Price from: $14.99 Free plan limits: Free one-time data exposure scan End-to-end encryption: All messages, emails and texts are encrypted inside Cloaked; zero-knowledge architecture with a separate encrypted database per user	Review Compare Visit
9	Cloaked 14 Days Free: 14 days free	8.2/10	Free	Price from: $14.99 Free plan limits: Free one-time data exposure scan End-to-end encryption: All messages, emails and texts are encrypted inside Cloaked; zero-knowledge architecture with a separate encrypted database per user	Review Compare Visit
10	Internxt Universal Technologies SL Christmas savings - Save 80%: 80% off	Not rated	No logs Business Free	Price from: €9.99 Free plan limits: 1 GB free encrypted cloud storage; Internxt Mail is only available with a premium plan End-to-end encryption: Emails and attachments in Internxt Mail are end-to-end encrypted with post-quantum and zero-knowledge encryption, so only the user can read them	Review Compare Visit
11	Apple Inc. Get 3 months of Apple One free with any new iPhone, iPad, or Mac: 3 months free	9.7/10	No logs Travel Free Budget	Price from: $0.99 Free plan limits: Aliases via Sign in with Apple are free with an Apple Account; changing the Forward To address requires iCloud+ End-to-end encryption: None of the mail is end-to-end encrypted: aliases are relayed and forwarded by Apple, which states it does not read or process message content except spam filtering	Review Compare See alternatives
12	addy.io Notesnook 25% off first year	9.5/10	Free Budget	Price from: $1 Free plan limits: Unlimited standard aliases, 10 active shared domain aliases, 1 recipient, 2 alias domains, 10MB monthly bandwidth End-to-end encryption: No end-to-end encryption of stored mail; optional GPG/OpenPGP encryption of forwarded messages to the recipient's own public key, including attachments and optional encrypted subject	Review Compare See alternatives
13	Apple Hide My Email 3 months of Apple One free: 3 months Apple One free	9.4/10	Free	Price from: $0.99 Free plan limits: Free 5GB iCloud plan excludes Hide My Email; it is included only with iCloud+ End-to-end encryption: None of the mail is end-to-end encrypted: aliases are relayed and forwarded by Apple, which states it does not read or process message content except spam filtering	Review Compare See alternatives
14	Runbox 30-day free trial of all plans: 30 days free, no credit card required	9.4/10	Budget	Price from: €1.66 Free plan limits: Free trial only (30 days): 1 GB email storage, 100 MB file storage, 20 recipients per day; no permanent free plan End-to-end encryption: No default end-to-end encryption; email is encrypted in transit only, and true E2EE is opt-in per message via S/MIME or PGP between sender and recipient	Review Compare See alternatives

About Top secure email and messaging compared

Secure email covers two different jobs here. Some members hand out aliases that forward mail to an address you already own, so a shop or a forum never sees your real inbox. Others are complete mailboxes, and a couple are messengers or network connections where encryption is built in. This ranking sets 60 brands across that mix, and it sorts on what you pay at the two moments that matter: the price you meet at signup, and the same service priced on a longer commitment. Those figures rarely match. The group median entry price is €4.38, while the longer-term price is €4.67, so a cheap opening can settle into a steady monthly charge. The second question is what the payment buys. Alias services are judged on custom domains, free limits and how the forward is protected. Mailboxes are judged on where the operator is registered and how encryption works between you and the person you write to. A free tier is normal here, at 78% of the group, so paying at entry is optional for a trial run.

How we picked

Every member here is scored on a weighted set of inputs, tuned for this category. Cost carries 40%, because the price at entry and the price on a longer commitment decide who keeps paying. The offer itself carries 40%, covering custom domains, free tier limits, open source code and how encryption actually works between you and the other party. Trust carries 20%, drawn from the registered legal entity, the headquarters country and the jurisdiction your data falls under. Each input comes from the provider's own material: support pages for encryption and alias behaviour, pricing pages for entry prices and plan models, legal notices and terms for the entity and jurisdiction, and encyclopaedia entries for founding years and headquarters. A limit stated by a provider is carried into the copy as stated rather than smoothed away, and a yes or no in the source is written as a yes or no. Partners, where a ranking carries any, are listed first and set apart from the scored order. Partners that serve your country are listed first in this ranking, then the rest by score.

How we rank

Our top picks

5. Proton AG
Proton AG sits in this ranking as the connection entry rather than a mailbox, and its encryption line is worth reading closely: what is protected is the tunnel from your device to Proton's servers, not the content of what you send. The company is Proton AG, founded in 2014, based in CH and answerable under CH law, with open source code. Its free plan is the open ended one in this group, covering a single device and servers picked at random from a limited set of countries at medium speed, as No data or speed limits, no ads, no time limit, 1 device, servers in 10 countries randomly selected, medium speed. sets out. Support runs on email, chat and help centre. SimpleLogin below forwards mail to your inbox and can encrypt a forward with your own key on a paid plan.
- Devices: 10
- Server countries: from 140
- No-logs audit: Securitum, 2026
Pros
- No-logs claims are audited rather than asserted: Securitum's audit (Securitum, 2026) sits behind a No activity logs policy.
- Free limits come with no caps on data or speed, no ads and no time limit.
- 10 simultaneous devices, above the ranked VPN median of 8.
- Servers in from 140 countries, with streaming for Netflix, Hulu and Disney+ and WireGuard and OpenVPN as the connection protocols.
- A single account carries the VPN, a passkey vault with end-to-end encryption and 5 GB of free storage, with GDPR, HIPAA and ISO 27001 compliance reported.
Cons
- Support runs on email, chat and help centre, and there is no phone line among them.
- The free plan limits put you on a single device at medium speed with randomly selected countries, so constant use points at a paid plan.
- End-to-end encryption is marketed for Proton for Business, while the consumer plan encrypts only the connection from your device to Proton's servers.
- The plan set is aimed at business buyers, so a home user ends up paying for features built around teams.

What to look for

Entry price, checked twice: The price shown at signup is not the whole story. The group median entry price is €4.38, while the longer-term price is €4.67. A service that looks cheap on a headline can settle higher once a trial ends, so read both figures on the same plan name before you commit.
What a free tier really allows: A free plan is common in this category, at 78% of the group, though the caps differ. Median free storage is 1. Alias services limit aliases or recipients, mailboxes limit storage and daily recipients. Posteo and Runbox sit outside the free tier group, so read their paid terms closely.
Custom domains for aliases: Custom domains are supported by 86.1% of the group, which lets an alias live on a domain you control rather than the provider's own. Apple Hide My Email, Apple Inc. and Posteo do not offer them. If you run a site, this decides whether your aliases can match your own name.
Open source code: Open source software appears in 69.8% of the group, covering addy.io, Posteo, Session, Runbox, Threema, Proton AG and SimpleLogin. Open code lets outside readers check what a service does with forwarded mail, which matters most where encryption is offered as an option rather than as the default.
Support you can actually reach: Help centres are close to universal here at 94.9%, with email support close behind at 81.4%. The Apple entries add phone lines, and Apple Inc. and Proton AG add live chat. Alias services tend to answer by email, so allow a reply into your support plans.
What the encryption claim covers: A no-knowledge claim is listed for 77.8% of the group, but the wording covers different things. Threema states it cannot read message content, Session encrypts chats and calls end to end, while the alias services encrypt in transit and offer key based encryption on some plans. Read where the claim applies.

Frequently asked questions

Is a free alias service as private as a paid mailbox?+

Not on encryption. The free tiers of addy.io and SimpleLogin hand out aliases and forward mail, but stored mail is not end-to-end encrypted at either. SimpleLogin can PGP-encrypt a forward with your own key on the Premium plan, and addy.io can encrypt forwarded mail to the recipient's public key with GPG or OpenPGP. Threema and Session protect message content end to end as standard, so that level of privacy sits on a paid plan with the alias services.

What is the difference between an alias and a real mailbox?+

An alias forwards to an address you already own, which is what Apple Hide My Email, Apple Inc., addy.io and SimpleLogin do. A mailbox stores the mail itself, which is what Posteo and Runbox provide, with webmail storage and custom domain support. Session and Threema sit outside both, carrying messages inside an app rather than a mailbox. The choice comes down to whether you want to keep your present inbox.

Which of these encrypt messages end to end by default?+

Threema and Session. Threema encrypts messages, voice and video calls including group calls, and shared files end to end between participants, and states it cannot read the content. Session encrypts direct messages, group chats, attachments and calls, though its Communities are encrypted in transit only. Posteo can protect individual webmail emails with S/MIME or OpenPGP, and Runbox offers that per message between sender and recipient. Apple relays and forwards aliases with no end-to-end encryption.

Do I need a custom domain?+

Custom domains are supported by 86.1% of this group, but not by every member: Apple Hide My Email, Apple Inc. and Posteo do not offer them. A custom domain keeps an alias on a name you control, which helps if you run a site. Without one, aliases sit on the provider's own domain, which is simpler but leaves the naming with them.

What will I pay at signup and afterwards?+

The group median entry price is €4.38 and the longer-term price is €4.67, so both are worth reading before you commit. A free tier is normal here, with 78% of the group offering a permanent free plan. Posteo and Runbox sit outside that group, so budget for the paid tier from the start. Prices are quoted in several currencies, so check what your own card will charge.

Why does the country of the company matter?+

Because the operator's home country sets which law your data falls under, and every member here names its jurisdiction. Session, Threema, Proton AG and SimpleLogin list CH, CH, CH and CH. Posteo sits in DE, Runbox in no, addy.io in GB and Apple in US. For readers inside the EU, a European entity is often the simpler starting point.

Ready to try Proton?

Ranked #1 of 10.

Visit